Skip to main content
Menu

PLC vs. DCS

At EPIC Automation, every practical, beneficial and cost-efficient automation solution we develop is based upon industry research and trends.  Before any design or development takes place, our engineers take the time to research and gain a thorough understanding of the process.  In October of 2011, Bill Lydon, Editor of Automation.com wrote an article called “PLC vs DCS – Competing Process Control Philosophy.” Below we have built a table of the differences he sees between the two controls platforms:

PLC

DCS

Common Applications

Non-core process functions including material handling, water treatment, motor controls, balance of plant operations, air compressor controls, packaging, and other functions Core processes (food, pharmaceutical, refining, etc.)

Control Architecture

Programming Model“Loose” component architectures allowing functions to be easily added with hardware and software Configuration ModelMulti-disciplined controllers for logic, sequential and process control, HMIs, custom applications, and business integration on one platform.

Price

No Significant DifferenceCompetitive with DCS No Significant DifferenceCompetitive with PLC

Enterprise Interface

PLC applications have caught up to DCS in recent years and most interface to business enterprise systems for information interchange and synchronized operations DCS systems have tied into the enterprise for years, conforming to the Purdue Model and more recently the ISA95 standard

Asset Management

PLCs are playing catch up Provide integrated software for a full range of devices and asset management standards

APC Advanced Process Control

Beginning to add functions and break into process control Offer a number of tools for optimizing control loops and more advanced alternatives to improve performance of PID control.

Total Production Optimization

Can be approximated with loosely coupled software add-ons Real-time software modeling and control optimization is an emerging function

Sensor/Control Network Communications

PLC systems tend to have less refined interfaces to Foundation Fieldbus and HART. In many cases they rely on third party hardware and software with configuration being more labor intensive. DCSs have highly refined and integrated interfaces to Foundation Fieldbus and HART and adequate interfaces to other industrial automation networks

DCS Backbone Network 

PLC systems use open published protocols that are designed to cover a wide range of applications including simple discrete, synchronized motion control, motor control, and process. PLC suppliers continue to add options for redundancy. All control functions can connect to one Ethernet backbone (process control, discrete, motion control, safety; etc.) In DCS systems, the process networks (Foundation Fieldbus, HART) and PLC-oriented networks (DeviceNet, Profibus, Modbus, etc.) are connected to controllers, which are connected to the process DCS backbone. DCS systems generally have easier to apply redundancy solutions but the open networking standard groups such as ODVA and PI International have defined solutions for their protocols particularly with the initiatives for networked machine safety.

Skid & Packaged Systems

Provided by skid vendor. Usually require field engineering to configure and maintain N/A

 

EPIC is a multi-discipline engineering firm specializing in automation and line integration. Our group of engineers works with manufacturers to transform individual pieces of machinery and equipment into fully functional, integrated production lines. To learn more about EPIC’s automation capabilities and PLC vs. DCS viewpoint,  contact an engineer today.

3 Responses to PLC vs. DCS

  1. priti jadhav December 13, 2017 at 12:12 am #

    PLC is the digital computer used in various industries to control the machine. PlC works only on specified task,
    DCS is the fully computerized software used in industries. DCS can control many processes at a time.

  2. mani April 20, 2018 at 6:33 am #

    Thank you for sharing. a great and helpful information

    Data Trace Automation have vast experience in Omron PLC Products like Omron Authorized System integrators, Distributors, Dealers in Chennai.

    We provide Best solutions to your Industrial Automation Applications.We are Omron Automation Traders and Supplier in Chennai.

    http://www.datatraceautomation.in/omron-plc

  3. LED Controls April 27, 2018 at 10:26 am #

    Thanks for this breakdown – you’ve made it very different to understand the difference between the two components.

Leave a Reply

Free Newsletter

Stay up-to-date on current industry news and trends by subscribing to our modular process newsletter. Our newsletters are sent out semi-annually and cover interesting news, trends, industry topics as well as updates on EPIC Systems.

EPIC Industrial Automation
4134 Meramec Bottom Rd
St. Louis, MO 63129, US
314-714-1580